By Alun John and Scott Murdoch
HONG KONG (Reuters) – Global banks and other financial institutions in Hong Kong are scrambling to find out details of China’s planned imposition of an anti-sanctions law on the city, and trying to understand how it could impact their operations in the financial hub.
Beijing adopted a law in June under which individuals or entities involved in making or implementing discriminatory measures against Chinese citizens or entities could be put on a government anti-sanctions list.
Financial firms are closely watching a meeting this week https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-top-legislature-discuss-adding-anti-sanctions-law-hong-kong-friday-media-2021-08-17 of the National People’s Congress Standing Committee, the highest organ of China’s parliament, for signs on how and when similar legislation will be introduced in Hong Kong.
Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam said on Tuesday she did not have an explicit timetable for its implementation.
The move came as the U.S. government imposed several rounds of sanctions on Hong Kong and Chinese officials over Beijing’s crackdown on the city’s freedoms under sweeping national security legislation.
Under the planned law, if financial institutions in Hong Kong implement U.S. sanctions, they may be exposed to legal risk in Hong Kong for doing so, financial sector executives and lawyers said.
“Many foreign multinational companies are asking about the impact of the anti-foreign sanctions law, especially international banks and financial institutions,” said Shaun Wu, a Hong Kong-based partner at law firm Paul Hastings.
“It is significant because international banks and financial institutions may find themselves caught between a rock and a hard place.”
Concerns have swirled over foreign financial institutions’ prospects in one of their most lucrative markets since Beijing’s implementation of the security law in the former British colony last year.
The anti-sanctions law now raises the spectre of financial firms getting caught in the crossfire as sparring between the world’s two largest economies escalates.
While top executives at Hong Kong’s biggest financial firms have not aired their concerns in public, people familiar with the matter said there had been intense discussions internally on how to deal with it.
A senior executive told Reuters that Hong Kong Financial Secretary Paul Chan had abruptly cancelled a meeting with business groups scheduled for Thursday, without providing a reason.
The executive, who declined to be identified due to sensitivity of the matter, said businesses were scrambling for information and Chan had made no effort to allay concerns despite repeated requests for meetings.
Offices of the Hong Kong government and Chan did not immediately respond to Reuters request for comment.
Hong Kong is the regional hub for many global financial firms, and accounts for the bulk of the profits for firms such as HSBC and Standard Chartered.
“Some of our financial institution clients are trying to plan out different scenarios ahead of the anti-foreign sanctions law, trying to decide what they would do if someone is sanctioned by the U.S. and subsequently run the risk of prosecution in Hong Kong for complying with such sanctions,” said Rod Francis, head of FTI Consulting’s financial crime practice.
“But while scenario planning is useful, there’s only so much of that kind of navel gazing you can actually do.”
LAW ENFORCEMENT
The U.S. last year imposed sanctions preventing American companies https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-china-hong-kong-sanctions-idUSKCN253215 and non-U.S. banks https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-hongkong-report-idUSKBN27008Q from doing business with several Chinese and Hong Kong officials whom it said implemented Beijing’s national security law on Hong Kong.
A separate U.S. ban on investments in companies Washington considers linked to China’s military forced U.S. banks in Hong Kong https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-usa-hkex-idUSKBN29F0EY to cut exposure this year to several Hong Kong-listed Chinese telcos.
A lawyer at one international law firm in Hong Kong said they had been inundated with calls regarding the anti-sanctions law but they were in no position to provide advice, given the complete lack of clarity.
“We’re waiting like everyone to see what is contained in the law … it’s hard to guess what will be in there,” one U.S. bank executive said, also declining to be identified.
Senior executives at two large foreign banks in China told Reuters they had not received any specifics about the law even in the mainland and their efforts to seek clarity from regulators had not been successful.
Some financial and legal professionals hoped Hong Kong would implement a watered-down version of the mainland law to make sure the city is able to maintain its finance hub status.
Paul Hastings’ Wu said a lot would depend on who will enforce the new rules and how. “That agency is going to determine, in practice, how wide the space between the rock and the hard place will be.”
(Reporting by Alun John, Scott Murdoch, Anne Marie Roantree in Hong Kong and Engen Tham in Shanghai; Writing by Sumeet Chatterjee; Editing by Kim Coghill)
