By Allison Lampert and Julie Gordon
(Reuters) – Global shipping and supply chain bottlenecks are encouraging Canadian firms to bring production back home, but some companies would have to absorb higher costs and build expertise in certain sectors for local manufacturing to pick up pace.
While carefully knitted global supply chains helped sectors from fashion https://www.reuters.com/article/benetton-reshoring-idCNL8N2QQ3N0 to autos cut costs and boost margins in recent decades, COVID-19 has eroded those advantages and exposed weaknesses like shortages of semiconductor chips.
In Canada, supply chain woes, recent rail and weather disruptions, along with pressure to source ethically and locally to lower emissions, are leading companies to buy closer to home or produce in-house, executives say.
Even before storms and Canada’s recent floods stranded two of its containers at the Port of Vancouver, Toronto-based Progress Luv2Pak was looking for more Canadian and U.S. suppliers due to soaring shipping costs and delays.
“In some cases, the value of the goods in the container are less than the freight,” said Ben Hertzman, president of Luv2Pak, which supplies shopping bags and other packaging for retailers.
He said about half of Luv2Pak’s seven-member buying team now focuses on North American sourcing, up from one part-time position just a few months ago, even though the company often gets better pricing and quality for products offshore.
Canadian manufacturing activity rose to a seven-month high in October, according to IHS Markit. Although it is too early to tell whether reshoring contributed to this rise, economists say companies are taking concrete steps toward buying local, unlike during earlier crises.
“This time around there’s not just talk of it, there’s actually action,” said Peter Hall, chief economist for Export Development Canada.
That’s driving cautious optimism that reshoring could bolster Canada’s manufacturing sector, which according to Statistics Canada data, has been in steady decline since the late 1990s.
Quebec’s investment arm recently launched its first “buy local” campaign aimed at companies and supply chains.
“The number of calls our ‘Buy Quebec’ team gets from companies each week is probably around 10 times higher than what it was even three months ago,” said Stephane Drouin, an executive with Investissement Quebec.
Quebec Economy Minister Pierre Fitzgibbon said in an interview he is pitching the advantages of North American-based supply to U.S. automakers like Tesla as the resource-rich province targets batteries for electric vehicles as a sector where it wants to compete globally.
Montreal-area furniture maker Artopex, which already sources mostly in Canada, is taking steps to make some components in-house that it once purchased in Asia due to delays and higher shipping costs, Chief Executive Daniel Pelletier said.
“It’s a major problem to not be able to have certainty over the timing of deliveries.”
Montreal-based business jet maker Bombardier has already brought aerostructure work in-house from North American suppliers outside its home province of Quebec and is looking at further reshoring opportunities, a spokesperson said.
Bombardier saw fewer production delays and improved quality after it repatriated work, such as the machining of stringers used in aircraft wings from a U.S. supplier, spokesperson Marie-Andree Charron said.
But policymakers warn reshoring is a “two-way-street” that risks hurting business if American producers eschew Canadians for U.S. suppliers.
“Firms in Canada may relocate production from offshore to Canada,” said Bank of Canada Deputy Governor Lawrence Schembri last week. “But other producers, for example the United States, may bring production from Canada back to the United States.”
Another challenge is a lack of expertise that would prevent Canada from quickly developing industries like semi-conductor chips, despite a global shortage.
“The auto industry is being held hostage by Taiwan and Korea,” Jerry Dias, the president of the country’s largest private sector union, Unifor.
Companies, however, like Luv2Pak see the benefits of local sourcing, given the uncertainty of imports.
“It would just be so nice to settle into some good supply lines that don’t have to come over an ocean,” Hertzman said.
(Reporting by Allison Lampert in Montreal and Julie Gordon in Ottawa; Editing by Denny Thomas and Lisa Shumaker)
